Відео

It says a lot about a show when the only well received episode is the one where all your characters are brutally murdered.

I think Qimir was another force sensitive kid Sol took for the Jedi, only this one against his will. Qimir hated it and eventually fled, ended up with a Sith teacher, hated that too and has decided to go his own way

Jecki held her own. Yorde actually came thru at the end but dang that was a tuff death

If the true sith comes in and takes out the stranger like sidious did to maul in clone wars. I will scream!!!

I say Qimir was on Brendok. It's hinted at that there is another child there. I think the Jedi find this out. Someone probably Qimir or his mother/sister possess a lot of the witches...you can see in the trailer where they are all sitting in the spot that they die with black eyes. It never actually shows Mae start the fire. It just shows her burn the book. I don't see them introducing any major sith lord. This is a simple revenge story.

She said "shape the story" not direct. You can infer what she meant, but that's just like your opinion man. Besides, Deborah Chow is a woman POC. Film is different than TV yes, but the implication that FINALLY A WOMAN is disingenuous as all get out.

You guys are some of the best at dissecting and discussing new canon. Keep on keeping on.

Hi Until now, the best interpretation and hypothesis... 👏 The detail of the music is incredible and connects with Ren, of course... The fact that Qimir wants to be free, beyond Jedi or Sith is remarkable. He wants to be something else. Like the Sith, he is a threat! Didn't Kylo Ren want the same with Rey? So, If Qimir dies, the Jedi just have to hide the facts! So typical of those who rule and want to keep the power, saying the Sith do not exist in the Galaxy... But Ren, Qimir, the Mothers, Osha, May, don't they use the Force differently, in a way even the Jedi are not aware of? Anyway, Thanks, your videos are great!

Much respect for giving a detailed response although I dont get how we can all be ok with a potential sith exposing himself carelessly 80 something years before Revenge of the Sith just to give the show more weight.. I think the Witch Mother who carried the twins might be the Big Bad guy and thats even worse because mind you, Plaguis and his master are still around.. I am going to hope that hes just a dark jedi or something of that sorts but I cant help but to feel that it takes away from the sith being in hiding for a millennium. Out of respect for whats already been established, I just hope theres some cleaning up. Because now it just feels like they are doing whatever they want to make something entertaining, canon breaking or not. Also Choco im not getting my info from YT or Twitter, Ive worked around and with Lucasfilm here in Marin County. Ive studied Star Wars since a kid. I get that things change but changing something as crucial as Ki Adi Mundis statement should not be overlooked or seen as minimal. Its a big reveal and its a big deal to have a powerful sith kill multiple jedi and act like nothing happened. Idk man, I give up honestly. We all have our own canon in our heads.

🤓☝️ well actually headass

While i love the fighting and smilo ren. I feel the writing is still sub par. In the previous episode, Mae says im going to turn myself in, my loyalty is to my sister. Then proceeds to fight (with intention to kill) jeckie, and then leaves her sister on the planet to fend for herself? So, everything she said in the previous episode is just a lie? If you're going to show brutality in the jeckie and Yord killings, why do the decapitation scene behind trees where we cant see it? Osha stops Sol to let bugs that can easily be defeated by lightsabers kill him instead? Sol cant sense that Mae isnt osha? Its just odd storytelling decisions.

Hi, Element and Choco! But... who is Qimir master? I wonder... which Darth? The episode was great! The plot is becoming more and more fascinating! Keep on with your videos!👍

I actually like episode 5. I thought the first 4 were boring but I thought the action was really good in 5. I tend to think that he isn't really sith. I think he found some books and or some knowledge about the darkside and when he said you might call me sith, the key word here being "might". I don't think he actually had a sith master.

I like how dark this episode was. There were alot of moments where smilo ren shoulda died though. It takes me out of it when people stand around like power rangers. Also why does Mae keep switching up? She wants to turn herself in but now shes finna infiltrate the jedi as a fake Osha? Weird. I still dont know how to feel about a sith exposing themselves 80 sum years before maul. So many holes. 5/10 episode though, had some cool action.

This series is getting quite a bit of, how should I say it, not to be "harmfull" to your feelings... it's getting a lot of backlash (rightfully so) all over the net. The director and writer must be amateurs because the dialogues are so simple and generic that I have never heard anything like this in my 50 years. No, sorry, I heard something like that in the movie The Room 2003. The actors are on the same level, there's no way you can't see it. I don't believe you like this and you can talk to me about it as much as you want and I'm not the only one. NOBODY believes you. Average audience score of 13% says it all. I hope that SW will change, because what amateurs release is on a completely different level and they do it out of their own pocket and we watch it for free. Did anyone here see ART OF THE SABER 18 years ago? 18 years??? And you call this "fight choreography". I understand that money is a good thing, but damage control doesn't work, what's more, it just adds fuel to the fire. Unlike many people, I KNOW what is happening, why it is happening and I also know where it will lead.

Why did you delete your video yesterday? I thought you made it to “shut up the haters” the you deleted it?

Was a solid episode, the fighting definitely made it a lot better. I hope this isnt the "Better fight that anakin vs obi wan" they were talking about cause if it is they fell short by quite a bit, also maes actress took me out of the episode a few times with her acting, other than that solid 6/7 out of 10

Do you really delete every negative comment?

You edited this so fast!

That episode was intense but that one death in particular really hurt. I was worried that was going to happen after last week which had solidified that character as my favorite and now their gone 😢

Jecki's death scene was one of the sadder Star Wars deaths but it was an honor to witness.

BEST EPISODE!! WE SITH ARE STRIVING!!!

I gotta give credit where it's due. That episode went hard Darth Swol over there. When did he get so ripped?

They deleted the “there are more of us vid” :skull:. I will know if they delete my comment

I personally think this show is disrespectful and poorly made and breaks canon having Ki Adi Mundi in there. Do you guys think its ok to have writers who know nothing about starwars be able to freely use characters and do things that negatively impact canon? I dont. I think its perfectly fine to give them a new era to work with that doesnt mess up whats already established. Also thank you for deleting that “more of us video”. It was not a good look using racial/diversity injustice as a pedal to defend a crappy show. Focusing on the small group of actual racist/bigot fans is wrong and shows that you are trying to gain from something thats been blown out of proportion. The loud minority of racists dont make up for even 2 percent of the fan base so im glad yall let that go. Also these actors arent oppressed and are literally laughing at all of us.

These fruitcakes defended the attk on Theory,, get life

oh please. stop shilling and trying to justify a terribly written and acted show. So because someone has a differing opinion they're automaticaly a racist, misogynistic, or bigot?

Great episode ! Always awesome hearing your thoughts!

You're great, Dyad! Your videos are really good because you discuss things! There is something interesting in this whole mistery...

I think Venestra is sus. So does Ki-Adi-Mundi. She shouldn’t have kept this secret from the High Council. To me it looks like they picked her and shaved her head to be a substitute for Yoda and Mace in order to protect them as legacy characters. It rhymes.

I need to rock a gummy bear shirt now. 😁 Love you guys.

Excellent discussion guys. I really appreciate good faith and knowledgeable analysis. Thanks!

Why is the audience rating for The Acolyte now lower than the Holiday Special?

Hi, you’re ideas are really interesting and different. I don’t think The Acolyte is trash, it’s surprisingly new, Star Wars is going forward, there’s something more than good and bad, Jedi and Sith. I love Jedi and Sith stuff, but this is also good! Thanks 🙏

LOL!Disney’s Acolyte just changed everything.

Qimir is Teeth! FANTASTIC EPISODE!!!! 😄😄😄

You guys are such a breath of fresh air. Love the breakdown!

Calling it now. The witches totally sacrificed like 100 people to create Mae and Osha

Ok... I'll go first. This agenda driven tripe is not Star Wars.

In the SW Galaxy, it was the law at the time up until thw Rise of the Empire. The Jedi would have the right to ask a family to give up a force sensitive child (family would be given enough to live comfortably & more), & the reason for this? The galaxy had just got over a period of a thousand years of war with Darksiders, including the Sith, who were bent on galactic domination. The only thing that stood in their way were the Jedi. The Jedi were given the permission to find Force Sensitives & hopefully have them join the Order. Why was this law? Because the chances of that force using child growing up to be a dark side war mongering psychopath were lessened exponentially (though not foolproof, obviously), if they went with the Jedi. It wasn't kidnapping. Parents had to give permission. This is CANON, ya just have to read.

Nah man the SWTOR cinematic pretty clearly shows them kidnapping babies

It’s fiction dude!

I'm very excited where this show will head. I am glad I discovery this channel and we need more balanced star wars content creators.

Anyone could always use whatever color they want. All the classes bullshit was for tabletop balancing, thank you guys for correcting this misconception. Any Jedi at any time could learn what ever it is they wanted and were never limited by a ridged class structure. The changing during the fight stuff was stupid IMO. If you don't go you of your way to "bleed" it (I still prefer synthetic crystals for the Sith) it should not turn red, especially since we have seen Anakin for instance be very dark with a blue saber. I think they should have stayed with the old each crystal just is different colored and if you like the green one you grab the green one or whatever.

THANK YOU! 😄 I thought I was going mad because I loved these episodes 😄 I was hooked from the beginning 😁

Don't forget Qui Gon tried bringing the mother along.

So where do they get all their padiwans your telling me it's ok to take an 6-10 year old as long as you ask them? They can't make that decision they are a child. They don't help the parents Anakins mother was in slavery and wound up dead if the chosen one isn't getting special treatment i doubt the other kids are

In legends there was a reference to these colors corresponding (I believe the word was "usually") to the Jedis "role" (this was in the Jedi Path book). So this was a Legends concept in that totality, however I agree, it was a garbage concept.The lore of Legends bending over backwards to try and fit into gameplay mechanics of games and TTRPGs has done such irreparable damage to the perception of the lore and universe.

It's impossible to name a more misunderstood thing in the Star Wars fandom 😂

Personally I don't get the complaining about violating the "did not exist for a mellnia." line. I'm pretty sure that back in Episode 1 when the line was written the logic was not "100% the Sith wen't extient in offical records 1,000 years before Phantom Menece." but more "the Sith have not been around for a long time." and well roughly 130 years is still a long time. With Yoda I think being the only council member alive during that era (Funny enough that would create a clear understanding to how did Yoda know of the Rule of Two despite the Sith of the Rule of Two not being known